- Tony Brown, charged with second-degree murder and weapons offenses in the March 2025 shooting death of Sanaa Food Market owner Ali Saleh, rejected an October plea offer.
- The offer would have reduced the case to first-degree manslaughter with a 23-year prison sentence plus five years of post-release supervision.
- Brown later pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter in December 2025 and received the same 23-years-plus-five-years sentence.
- Prosecutors said the shooting was retaliation tied to a prior conflict, and Salehs family stressed the importance of an admission of guilt for healing.
Read More
The case of Tony Brown illustrates complex prosecutorial decision-making in violent crime matters, especially where plea bargaining offers can balance certainty of conviction against risk, resources, and impact on victims and community. Originally charged with murder, Brown’s refusal of the plea in October suggested either legal strategy (perhaps preserving defense options) or hesitation to admit diminished culpability. This refusal delayed resolution and prolonged uncertainty for Saleh’s family and the community.
However, the subsequent plea to first-degree manslaughter in December demonstrates prosecutors were able to reach a resolution that matched much of the proposed plea terms in October, including sentencing. This outcome provides prosecutors with certain convictions and admission of guilt, avoiding the risks of trial and potentially harsher penalties being overturned or lessened. For the defense, the plea likely reflected a calculation that the negotiated term was preferable to facing trial on second-degree murder which could carry greater penalties.
The community response, including the strong victim impact statements and public recognition of Saleh’s role in the neighborhood, underscores the non-legal dimensions in such cases: beyond punishment, admission of guilt and acknowledgment are seen as essential for community healing. The plea hearing allowed some of that, which a trial might delay or limit if Brown had disputed aspects of motive or responsibility.
Strategically, this case has implications for how plea offers are constructed and timed. The fact that the offer made in October closely aligned with the final sentence suggests such offers can be effective. But the interim period—in which Brown declined—speaks to negotiation costs: delay of justice, emotional toll, public scrutiny. It raises questions about how to design plea incentives, communicate risks to defendants, and manage public expectations.
There remain open questions: What evidence strength pushed Brown toward eventually accepting the plea? Did external pressure (sample: from community, legal cost, or risk of trial outcome) play a role? Are there policy reviews underway in Monroe County DA’s office regarding plea deals in murder cases, especially involving community-affecting crimes?
Supporting Notes
- Tony Brown was charged with second-degree murder and weapons charges after shooting Ali Saleh multiple times in Sanaa Food Market in March 2025.
- Prosecutors offered a plea deal in October 2025 reducing charges to first-degree manslaughter with a sentence of 23 years in prison plus five years post-release supervision, which Brown initially rejected.
- Brown eventually pleaded guilty to first-degree manslaughter and was sentenced in December 2025 to 23 years in prison and five years supervised release.
- The motive was alleged retaliation for a previous conflict involving Saleh’s employee; Brown approached the store and shot Saleh at close range behind the counter.
- Saleh was found on March 23, 2025 behind the counter with gunshot wounds, taken to Strong Memorial Hospital, and died the next day.
- In court, Saleh’s widow, family, and community members emphasized Saleh’s kindness, community service, and the emotional pain of the loss; focus was placed on admission of guilt being a component of justice.
- Court proceedings included initial plea rejection (October), and final sentencing on December 19, 2025.